The Babysitters (2007) streaming

The Babysitters is a 2007 independent drama film directed by David Koryaka. It stars John Leguizamo, Cynthia Nixon and Katherine Waterston. Wikipedia
Cast

John Leguizamo (Michael Beltran)
John Leguizamo
Michael Beltran

Alexandra Daddario (Babara Yates)
Alexandra Daddario
Babara Yates

Cynthia Nixon (Gail Beltran)
Cynthia Nixon
Gail Beltran

Andy Comeau (Jerry Tuchman)
Andy Comeau
Jerry Tuchman